On-premise AI vs cloud AI: how they differ
- Updated
- By
- The MagnolIA team
- On this page
- 11 min read
Short answer
With cloud AI, every prompt leaves the office with the document inside it, is processed on another company's servers and is billed per use. With on-premise AI, the model runs on hardware in your network, the data stays there and the cost is fixed. Cloud wins on immediacy; on-premise wins on control.
When does each one win?
Neither is better at everything. The choice depends on what information will be handled, how many people will use it and who is going to maintain it.
Cloud wins when…
- You need to start today, without installing anything.
- A few people use it, occasionally, with information that is not sensitive.
- You need one specific proprietary model that only its maker offers.
- Demand changes a lot from one month to the next.
On-premise wins when…
- Documents cannot leave the organisation: professional secrecy, health data, case files, source code.
- Many people use it, or use it heavily, and pay-per-use spend already exceeds a fixed fee.
- You must be able to show who used what and when, with a log that is not held by a third party.
- The service has to keep working even if the connection goes down.
On-premise AI and cloud AI, point by point
| Criterion | Cloud or API-based AI | On-premise AI |
|---|---|---|
| Where the data lives | On the provider's servers. The document leaves your network with every prompt. | On the hardware installed in your network. The document does not leave. |
| How you pay | Per user or per use. The bill grows with usage. | Fixed cost: buying the hardware, or a fee that does not depend on consumption. |
| Who maintains it | The provider. There is nothing to operate. | Your technical team or, in the managed model, the provider. |
| Which models are available | Each vendor's proprietary models and, on some services, open-weight ones too. | Open-weight models, which run on your own hardware. |
| How it scales | Instantly, up to the limits of the plan you pay for. | By adding hardware. Capacity is sized in advance. |
| Dependence on the internet | Total: no connection, no service. | Everything that depends on the model works without an internet connection. |
| Compliance | A third party processes the data: its contract and processing locations need reviewing. | The document is not sent to an outside provider. Usage records stay in your installation. |
| What can change without your say | Price, terms of use and the models on offer: the provider can withdraw or replace one. | Installed models do not change unless someone changes them; in a managed service the provider updates them. Hardware ages and has to be replaced. |
| Time to get started | Minutes: an account and a card. | Hardware has to be installed and a pilot run before opening it to all staff. |
Where is the data in each case?
In the cloud, the document travels inside the prompt to the provider's servers and is processed there. A business plan sets out by contract how it is handled, but it does not change the route: the data has left your network.
On-premise, the document goes from the person's computer to the machine in the office and back. In a MagnolIA installation, the only thing that travels outside is monitoring of the machine's status: load, health and security. MagnolIA does not see prompts, documents or answers.
Under the GDPR, the difference is fundamental. With on-premise AI the document is not sent to an outside provider and does not leave the EU. That does not replace the assessment of each processing activity, which remains your organisation's job, but it makes it simpler. The specific measures are on the on-premise AI security page.
How do you pay: per use or a fixed fee?
Cloud AI is paid per use: a licence per person, a price per volume of text processed, or both. Starting is cheap, and spend grows with every user and every automation.
On-premise AI has a fixed cost. If you buy the hardware, that is an upfront investment plus its upkeep. With MagnolIA it is a monthly fee per capacity tier that includes the hardware, the software, the models, support and integrations, and does not change with consumption.
On-premise pays off when monthly spend on subscriptions, licences and APIs exceeds that fee, which usually happens with more people or heavy use. The on-premise AI cost calculator estimates it from your figures and tells you if you would not save.
Which costs should you include for a fair comparison?
A common mistake is comparing the cloud invoice with the price of a machine. Each option has cost lines the other lacks, and there are three options, not two.
| Cost line | Cloud or API | Purchased on-premise | Managed on-premise |
|---|---|---|---|
| To get started | Next to nothing. | Buying the hardware and installing it. | Nothing to buy: the hardware is in the fee. |
| Every month | Per-seat licences and usage by volume of text. It rises with use. | Electricity, maintenance and the hours of whoever runs it. | A fixed fee per capacity tier. |
| Technical staff | Not needed to operate the service. | Needed: it is a line that is easily forgotten. | Supplied by the provider. |
| When the team grows | More licences and more usage. | Another hardware purchase. | The provider adds capacity. |
| When a better model appears | The provider decides; the price may change. | Someone has to evaluate and install it, if it fits on the hardware. | The provider brings it in. |
| At the end | You cancel. Anything built on a specific model has to be adapted. | The hardware is yours, with whatever value it retains. | It depends on the contract. With MagnolIA you choose between keeping the hardware, renewing it or returning it. |
Doing your own sums takes four steps: add up what you spend per month in the cloud; add up what on-premise would cost per month, with every line in the table; subtract; and, if you bought the hardware, divide the purchase price by that difference to see how many months it takes to recover. If the difference is negative, on-premise saves nothing and the reason to install it has to be a different one. No payback period holds for everyone: it depends above all on how much the hardware is used. The cost lines for purchased hardware, and what one academic study of that period does and does not say, are in self-hosting an LLM.
Which models are available on each side?
They are not the same, and it is better to know that before deciding. The big providers' proprietary models are only offered in their own clouds: they cannot be installed on your own hardware.
On-premise AI works with open-weight models, whose parameters are published and can run on any machine with enough capacity. MagnolIA selects, tests and updates them, with profiles per task: quick answers, code, writing or in-depth analysis. When a better one appears, MagnolIA brings it in without users having to switch tools.
Nor is it all or nothing. If your organisation chooses to, MagnolIA Nexus can work with an external provider's account alongside your server's models, and the document anonymiser lets that external model receive only the copy with personal data removed.
Is there a middle ground? Managed on-premise AI
Yes. Managed on-premise AI keeps the data in your network, as on-premise does, and leaves operations to the provider, as the cloud does. It answers the main drawback of running your own server: somebody has to maintain it. The two options are compared in self-hosted LLM: build or buy.
With MagnolIA you do not buy the machine: it is hardware as a service, included in the fee. MagnolIA installs it in your office, maintains and updates the models, monitors the service and adds capacity when your team grows, without downtime. How it is built is explained in MagnolIA's AI server.
Can you use both at once? The hybrid model
Yes, and it is a common arrangement: sensitive and everyday work inside; the occasional task that needs one specific model outside. What it takes is a rule anyone in the office can apply without asking.
| Type of work | Where | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Documents with personal data, case files, client contracts, your own code | On-premise | The document does not leave the network. |
| Daily use by all staff: summarising, drafting, minutes | On-premise | It is the volume that makes pay-per-use expensive. |
| Public information, or nothing that identifies anyone, with one specific proprietary model | Cloud | There is little to protect and that model is not offered outside its cloud. |
| A sensitive document that needs an outside model | Cloud, with the document anonymised first | The outside model receives the copy without personal data. |
The risk with hybrid is that the rule is not followed and the sensitive document ends up in the outside tool out of convenience. You reduce it by making the in-house tool the most convenient for daily work. The ways of keeping data away from third parties are compared in private AI for business.
When is on-premise AI not the right choice?
There are situations where the cloud is the sensible option, and it is better to know before installing anything.
- You are a small team and use it little. If current spend on licences and APIs is below a fixed fee and the information is not sensitive, on-premise does not save money.
- You depend on one specific proprietary model. If a workflow is built on a model that only exists in its maker's cloud, it cannot be brought into the office.
- The load is unpredictable. Your own hardware has fixed capacity. If demand multiplies one week and vanishes the next, cloud elasticity is a better fit.
- You only want to experiment. To explore what AI can do for a few weeks, a cloud service with non-sensitive data is enough.
- There is nowhere to put it and nobody to run it. Without a provider to manage it or an in-house technical team, an AI server ends up neglected.
How do you decide? Five questions
What information will the AI handle?
If it includes health data, case files, professional secrecy or proprietary code, start with on-premise. There are examples by industry in the on-premise AI use cases.
How many people will use it, and how often?
With many people or daily use, a fixed cost works out better than paying per use.
What do you spend today on licences and APIs?
That is the number to compare with a fixed fee.
Who is going to maintain it?
With no technical team, the options are the cloud or managed on-premise, not a server run on your own.
Do you need one specific proprietary model?
If so, that use stays in the cloud. The rest may not have to.
If you would like to see AI that does not keep your documents in action before deciding, the MagnolIA LAB has free tools. And the starting definition is in what on-premise AI is. What it looks like in a team's daily work is covered in AI in the office.
Frequently asked questions about on-premise and cloud
How is on-premise AI different from cloud AI?
With cloud or API-based AI, every prompt leaves the office with the document inside it, is processed on another company's servers and is billed per use. With on-premise AI, the model runs on hardware in your network, the data stays there and the cost does not depend on consumption.
When does on-premise AI pay off compared with paying per use?
On-premise AI pays off when monthly spend on subscriptions, licences and API usage exceeds the fixed fee of the tier you need, which usually happens with more people using AI or with heavy use. The calculator estimates it from your figures and tells you if you would not save. In regulated sectors the reason is usually privacy, not savings.
What costs should you add up to compare on-premise AI with the cloud?
To compare on-premise AI with the cloud, add up the per-seat licences and API usage of the whole team on the cloud side; on the on-premise side, if you buy the hardware, add the purchase price, electricity, maintenance, the hours of whoever runs it and replacing it in due course. With MagnolIA's managed service those items sit inside one fixed fee.
When is on-premise AI not worth it?
On-premise AI is not worth it when only a few people use it, occasionally, with information that is not sensitive: licence spending stays below a fixed cost. Nor when the work depends on a proprietary model offered only in the cloud. MagnolIA's calculator says so when your own figures show no saving.
What happens if my team grows?
If your team grows, capacity is added without downtime: MagnolIA adds hardware to the Núcleo without interrupting the service and without anything changing for users. The server distributes requests across the available machines and keeps each conversation on the same one to make use of its cache.
Does the AI work if the internet goes down?
Whatever runs on the machine in your network keeps working without the internet. In the installation we describe as a real case, the machine was tested with the internet cut off before handover and kept reading documents and answering: it does not depend on any external service. Without a connection there is, naturally, no remote monitoring or web search.
Sources
External figures on this page link to their original source.
EUR-Lex. Regulation (EU) 2016/679, General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR). eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/reg/2016/679/oj
Undecided between the two? Let's look at your numbers
Tell us how many people would use AI, with what information and what you spend today. If the cloud suits you better, we will say so too.
Request a pilot


